Meeting/Event: Human rights in Nicaragua: advancing towards accountability - Third Committee Side Event, General Assembly, 81st session Date: 27 October 2026 Categories: Meetings & Events > General Assembly > 81st Session [Auto-generated transcript: may contain errors] Everyone, good afternoon. Welcome to this event, Human Rights in Nicaragua: Advancing Towards Accountability. I'm Carlos Quesada, the executive director of the Institute on Race, Equality, and Human Rights. We're thank you for being with us today in the Human Rights in Nicaragua: Advancing Towards Accountability. The colectivo 46.2, together with GREM and sponsored by the Mission— the Permanent Mission of Chile in the United Nations, we have organized in the— has organized within the framework of the Interaction Dialogue with the Group of Experts on Human Rights in Nicaragua, following the presentation of its report to the Third Committee. Colectivo 46.2 brings together 23 Nicaraguan regional and international organizations working to promote accountability regarding the human rights situation in Nicaragua. We thank the Permanent Mission of Chile to the United Nations for co-sponsoring this event, and particularly its ambassador, Robert Ampuero, who is here with us today. We also thank the other diplomatic delegations that are here with us. Ambassador Roberto Ampuero is a distinguished public servant, former Minister of Foreign Affairs of Chile, and Chile's ambassador to Mexico and Spain. He is also a renowned writer, with more than 20 published works. Mr. Ambassador, I would like to please, uh, offer the welcoming remarks. Thank you. The microphone is very loud. Thank you. Ladies and gentlemen, Chile is pleased to be part of this event that offers a great opportunity to examine the situation of human rights in Nicaragua, and also reflect on the necessary efforts to promote respect and fundamental rights and accountability. I would like to start by thanking the Group of Experts on Human Rights in Nicaragua and Colectivo 46/2 for this event. I would also like to thank the important role of social— civil society and the person on human rights in that country. Over 80 years from the start of the crisis in 2008, the evolution of the events in Nicaragua continues to be a serious consideration for Nicaragua and the international community. In 2008, I became Minister of Foreign Affairs of Chile. That's one of the first topics that I had to give a position on, and we did it in a very concise way. The recent experts' report discusses violations and the seriousness and the growth of practices that affect the exercise of human rights and security, personal security. In December of this year, there was a report that documented at least 161 cases of forced disappearances starting in 2018. I saw it before. And the death of political prisoners. It has to do with a background that are especially serious, that require clarification, investigation, independent investigation, and efficient measures in order to avoid repetition. Among these cases are human rights—indigenous human rights— Misquito Brooklyn Rivera, who died under the state's custody in May of last year, after having been incarcerated for a long time. This situation showed the need to guarantee the protection of everyone that is imprisoned without a difference, just as the—such as the— in addition to the respect of indigenous peoples. For Chile, it's very important to remember that personal security and the guarantees of due process are essential obligations of the states. Therefore, we reiterate the importance of bringing an end to enforced disappearances, freeing prisoners that have been detained arbitrarily, and guarantee access by their family members to information regarding their status. Ladies and gentlemen, another aspect that deems right attention is the size of the— the growth of the situation in Nicaragua. The expert group has documented surveillance practices, threats, and harassment against Nicaraguans who are also— who also reside overseas. This presents challenges that go over international borders and requires a reaction based on respect of international laws and the respect of human rights. In the institutional area, we observe with great concern the recent constitutional changes and the restrictions of political participation that deepen the concerns over the role of democratic institutions and the fundamental guarantees in Nicaragua. For Chile, democracy is not limited to an election. It requires solid agency, separation of rights, the respect of the—of the rule of law, and conditions that are effective for the exercise of civil and political rights. These principles constitute essential elements of democratic institutionality, and they must be safeguarded with independence from political ideologies and governments. In this sense, we value the joint declaration issued on October 1 by the Human Rights Inter-American Organization and the experts group, which highlighted the relationship between the enforcement of human rights, democracy, and the reestablishing of rule of law in Nicaragua. Hence, Chile reaffirms once again its commitment with the international system of the— for the protection of human rights and the work of its independent mechanisms. Within this framework, we recognize the important contribution of the Group of Experts on Human Rights in Nicaragua, whose work allows us to have documented analyses and expert analyses in order to understand the evolution and the situation, to be able to identify responsibilities and contribute towards the efforts of accountability. The cooperation by the states with international mechanisms of— on human rights constitute a very important element on the compliance of its international obligations, the fulfilling of international obligations. Therefore, we call on Nicaragua's authorities in order to undertake effective cooperation with such mechanisms and adopt the necessary measures to guarantee the full respect of human rights of its population. In the same line, we consider that international exports must be geared towards favoring conditions that enable the strengthening of democratic institutions, the protection of fundamental liberties, and access to justice. Having in due account—taking in due consideration— the rights and needs of the victims and their families. International experience shows that respect of institutions, the legal guarantees, and the existence of effective mechanisms of accountability are conditions that are vital in the stability and democratic life. Ladies and gentlemen, Chile will continue to approach Nicaragua's situation from its commitment to human rights, international law, the protection of human rights, giving priority to multilateral cooperation and the strengthening of institutional mechanisms. We are confident that this gathering will contribute to a substantial interchange on current exchanges and the available pathways to move towards justice, truth, and accountability. Our purpose must be that everyone in Nicaragua may be able to exercise their rights and freedoms surrounded by respect of human dignity and the rule of law. Thank you very much. Thank you very much. And now, we want to thank the state of Chile for everything it's been doing for the people of Nicaragua. Thanks very much. Next, we will show a prerecorded video by Commissioner Rosa María Payá, the Inter-American Commission's rapporteur for Nicaragua. Greetings. The expert group for human rights, Colectivo, the Permanent Missions, the organiz—civil society organizations, victims, and their family members. I thank you for this opportunity and in representation of the Inter-American Human Rights Commission. Ladies and gentlemen, over 80 years of the crisis in Nicaragua, international mechanisms have documented serious violations of human rights. It's been identified by— it's identified patterns and contributed to reestablishing accountability. However, violations continue; impunity persists. The challenge is no longer documenting abuses only; it is achieving that such documentation become effective protections: the preservation of evidence, access to justice, and sustainable action to address impunity. The reforms in 2025 consolidated the concentration of powers in vice presidency of Daniel Ortega and Rosario Murillo. In 2026, a new reform pursues prolonging its mandates and restricting political rights of those who are considered to be dissident. The disassembling of democratic institutions had left victims practically without effective resources for their protection within the nation. Based on Memory and Justice Institution, on 24 September, 78 people were still political prisoners, and out of them, 31 were in force situation situation. Misquito leader Ruby Misquito died after being disappeared since 2023. This year, we have adopted 15 resolutions of injunctions in order to protect individuals who are in serious and urgent situations. Persecution also reaches those that try to exercise legal and independent justice. There have been reporting of the exclusion of 2,000 lawyers and notaries from professional registries in Nicaragua, and repression has surpassed borders. Attacks against Nicaraguan opponents, they limits the— it's an evidence that the states need to cooperate in order to protect those that are in exile. Ladies and gentlemen, the lack of cooperation of the Nicaraguan regime should not represent the abandonment of victims or the— or the freezing of the protection, international protection mechanisms. It demands strengthening the complement—complementary actions. The Commission recognizes the fundamental contribution of the Group of Experts on Human Rights on Nicaragua and the office of the High Commissioner of Human Rights for the— for Human Rights. Its work is essential in order to preserve the evidence, to highlight responsibilities, and facilitate future justice processes. Through Ms. Sen, the CIDH will continue to document violations by reviewing the situation and supporting victims. Documentation should not be a replacement for the responsibility of the states. And October 2, in the 31st meeting of consultation of the OAS, it was agreed that a ministerial group of review should be structured in order to promote dialogue and discuss concrete and legal measurements. so that the temporary reduction in the number of people incarcerated does not reflect less repression, but rather a strategy of managing fear and social attrition. Enforced disappearance is today one of the cruelest forms of repression. What began in 2018 as a temporary practice has become a structural feature of political imprisonment in the country. People remain for months or years in solitary confinement, without contact with their families, without access to legal defense, and without no information regarding their health status. The risk of disappearance no longer depends solely on a person's political involvement, but also on the regime's perception that they have of them and the intimidating effects that this may have. Today, relatives of political prisoners, non-activists, and former officials are among those who have disappeared. The most reprehensible case involves two minors who were imprisoned alongside their mother, Elvia Castillo Flores, beginning in March 2025. All three have been missing ever since. The most extreme consequence of this system is death in state custody. Since 2018, according to our records, at least nine political prisoners have died in custody, four of them between August 2025 and May 2026. The working group on enforced disappearances warned that these deaths occurred under conditions that could constitute torture. And finally, transnational repression. Leaving Nicaragua has not meant the end of persecution. The repression has taken on a clear transnational dimension that extends to opposition figures in exile, in Costa Rica, and other host countries. We have documented more than 200 cases involving surveillance, monitoring, threats, harassment, attacks, murders, confiscation of property, denaturalization, arbitrary denial of entry into the country, and the use of international police cooperation for persecution. These practices are complemented by smear campaigns, online threats, and retaliation against family members who remain in Nicaragua. At the same time, the state uses the border as a tool for punishment. It expels or prevents the return of individuals considered critical, and at the same time restricts access to identity documents and consular services, hindering their protection, regularization, and integration in host countries. Costa Rica accounts for a significant portion of the documented cases of transnational repression. The attacks against Joao Maldonado and Nadia Robledo, as well as the murders of Jaime Luis Chavarria and Roberto Samkam, highlight the risks that exiles continue to face. In 2026 alone, there were two assassination attempts against Nicaraguan opposition figures, Reynaldo Picado, and two attacks against a journalist. In Honduras, Marvin Gámez and his wife were shot in an attack in a context where at least five Nicaraguan exiles were murdered between 2019 and 2023. These incidents demand independent investigations to determine responsibility and possible links to transnational persecution networks. This pattern is also evident in extradition proceedings and the misuse of Interpol red notices. Among the cases are those of Douglas Pérez Centeno, extradited from Costa Rica in 2023 and who actually is a victim of enforced disappearance in the jails of Nicaragua, and Pedro Fernández and Reynaldo Picado, who were sought via red notices and whose extradition to Nicaragua was prevented through legal action and the support of civil society organizations in Costa Rica. The persecution also seeks to silence those who continue to speak out from exile. Reprisals against family members who remain in Nicaragua serve this purpose. Fear forces many people to change their homes, abandon economic activities, or limit contact with their loved ones in order to protect them. In some cases, the ongoing risk leads to further displacement to third countries. Leaving Nicaragua and even being recognized as a refugee does not guarantee that persecution has ended. These facts demonstrate that repression in Nicaragua has transformed, expanded, and become more sophisticated. Today, it combines political and religious persecution, forced disappearances, and killings, denaturalization, the disclosure of civic space, the weakening of constitutional guarantees, and actions that even reach people outside the national territory. Thanks very much. Thank you very much, Claudia. I would like to highlight two numbers from your presentation, which are a sub-record: 72 political prisoners, 33 that have been disappeared. And why do we highlight this? Because many family members do not report enforced disappearance or imprisonment of their loved ones. We really wanted to highlight this. Thank you so very much. Now we have Claudia Paz y Paz, who will discuss differentiated impacts on women, Indigenous peoples, and people of African descent. Claudia. Thank you very much, Carlos. I would like to begin by noting that I'm speaking on behalf of the feminist, Indigenous, and Afro-descendant organizations that make up Colectivo 46'2. Several of these organizations cannot publicly acknowledge their participation in this forum due to the risk of reprisals by the Nicaraguan state. This situation itself reflects the severe restrictions on civic space in the country. We would also like to highlight the joint declaration regarding the human rights situation in Nicaragua, led by Costa Rica on September 21st on the 63rd Session of the Human Rights Council. This declaration includes countries from the Americas, Europe, and Asia Pacific. It was also signed by Chile. It reports a decision by the Nicaraguan government to not have more elections with the opposition. The death under custody of Brooklyn, the systematic persecution of Indigenous peoples, transnational repression, and rejection of Nicaragua to cooperate with the United Nations. The 47 states make this urgent call for the liberation of those that have been arbitrarily detained, the access to genuine cooperation with the UN, including periodic universal reviews. We have the support of these delegations in order to carry out joint initiatives similar in future sessions of the Third Commission. I wanted to mention this from the onset of my presentation, given that it is highly important, while also highlight that in terms of repression, it affects everyone in the same does not affect everyone in the same way. In order to achieve its scope, we must analyze its discrimination motives and the impact that it has on communities. The movement of women, the feminist movement, had historically defended human rights and the rule of law. Its leaders have been persecuted not only for expressing political dissent but also for challenging the gender roles that the authorities seek to impose. According to the Mesoamerican Registry of attacks on women defenders, between 2018 and 2025, nearly 14,000 attacks were documented against more than 1,700 women defenders in 400 organizations. These include threats, surveillance, criminalization, physical, psychological, and sexual violence. Investigations into these patterns identify indications of gender-based discriminatory motivation, which must be considered when examining possible crimes of persecution under international criminal law. More than 300 women defenders and activists have been arbitrarily detained or prosecuted since 2018. One of them, who is still disappeared, is Thelma Montenegro, a member that was detained on August 23rd of this year. She is a member of the Asociación de Madres de Abril. Thelma, through years, has demanded truth and justice for the disappearance of four family members under repression. This case, her case, shows how persecution and repression also affect women who demand justice for their loved ones. More than 350 women who are human rights defenders have been forcibly displaced or disappeared. In exile, family separation, caregiving responsibilities, and economic insecurity exacerbate the impacts, especially for older women. Added to this is the arbitrary closure of women's and feminist organizations, which has dismantled networks providing shelter, legal counsel, and psychological support for women and girls facing violence. The impact of or the case of Nancy Enrique illustrates how gender-based persecution intersects with attacks on Indigenous leadership. This mosquito leader, a former congresswoman and president of the Yatama Party, was released from prison in March 2026 after more than two years of arbitrary detention. However, she remains under house arrest in a family home far from her territory. Her release has not meant the restoration of her full freedom or the reestablishment of her community ties. On the Caribbean coast, the persecution of traditional authorities and Indigenous leaders is intertwined with land occupation, the erosion of autonomy, and the expansion of extractive activities. Although 23 Indigenous territories in the country have been officially titled, the state has not completed the land regularization necessary to resolve the presses of settlers on communal lands. At least 79 Indigenous people were killed between 2013 and 2024 during invasions and attacks by settlers. Added to this is the imposition of parallel government structures that weaken or replace the traditional authorities selected by the communities. The case of Brooklyn Rivera, a historic mosquito Indigenous leader and member of Congress, illustrates the severity of the persecution. He was detained and remained missing for 971 days without a court conviction. Three days before his death, his whereabouts were revealed, and he was found in critical condition. His case highlights the devastating effects of enforced disappearance and prison conditions and shows how repression seeks to destroy leadership, punish communities, and sow fear beyond prison walls. Eight family members and close associates were imprisoned for demanding the return of his body, and all are currently considered victims of enforced disappearance. To date, at least 20 Indigenous people are being held in detention for political reasons, including eight Mayanga Forest Rangers whose work was to defend their territories and two Mayangua farmers for defending Indigenous territories. The criminalized effects not only affect those detained but also the communities that depend on their work, just like surveillance, interrogatories, and retaliation. Violence against Indigenous peoples continues. On October 18th, armed settlers attacked the Mayana community in Dynamaguas, where Dionisio Hernandez Bruno and his son, Wilmer Hernandez, were murdered. The attack left wounded. The burning of dwellings and over 20 families were forcefully disappeared. Also, the effect of exorcises of they have state societies have impeded the safeguards and transparency on mining concessions. That affects effective rights to autonomy and free and informed consent. Investigations of civil society identify 75 mining concessions that affect 19 protected areas and two biosphere reserves. These mining concessions in the hands of Chinese organizations cover 12.5 percent of national territory. In. US peoples and Afro-descendant peoples on the Nicaragua coast are at cultural risk; therefore, accountability demands that these patterns be recognized. Accountability requires recognition of the discriminatory motivations, the individual and collective harms, and the responsibility of perpetrators. The investigation of these violations and the effective participation of victims and communities in justice processes are indispensable for moving forward truth, reparations, and guarantees of non-repetition. Thank you very much, Claudia, especially for highlighting the differential effect of conflict on women, Afro-descendants, and Indigenous peoples in Nicaragua, especially in the most recent cases that you mentioned from October. Now we will hear from Rebe Roddy, a member of GHREN, who will tell us about recent findings and some recommendations. Thank you. Thanks to the Colectivo. Thanks to Chile on behalf of my colleagues Daniela and Michael Simone. Ambassador, you have known from close dictators, and you have told us today I've read that you said that no dictatorship is good, nor from the right or the left. My presentation will be focused on accountability, because that was a Chilean case also that changed international justice. In October of 1998, Auguste Pinochet was arrested in London, and I was lucky enough to coordinate the legal team of Human Rights Watch before the legislative chambers. Chilean Attorney Roberto Garreton was included. Twenty-five years before then, from solidarity of the Catholic Church, Roberto had presented over 1,000 relief resources or requests for relief by detainees or persons that had been imprisoned, but none of them were approved. In London, Roberto or I was asking myself, why do all those demands? Pinochet understand, I realized that all that was worthwhile. That has been my experience in many cases. I had the same experience in Chad. Suleman Gangen, who survived for years from imprisonment, he collected over 800 testimonies on his release, but with the accomplices in power, they were hidden under his house floor. But after the decision, those Suleman documents opened a pathway for the conviction of Eisenhower in Senegal. What is the lesson learned for or the lesson that Nicaragua should learn? Our group has highlighted the accountability, and last year we identified 56 persons regarding whom there are reasonable reasons to believe that they are responsible for serious violations and crimes. Among them, obviously, we have Daniel Ortega and Rosario Murillo, but also 11 members of the Army and 9 police members, 11 judges and justices, officers of the Ministry of the Interior and the prison system, mayors, prosecutors who are responsible for communications and social security. Our reports have charts, which is an initiative by my colleague Jan, with charts that show the chain of command for each of each of or linked to each violation that name. Those charts that list are they are a message to each Nicaraguan official, whether or not they're included on the list, that there's an open file that human rights crimes do not have a stature of limitations. Amongst our group, we have identified four solid pathways for accountability. Court the International. First of all, the International Court of Justice. For us, the most efficient measure would be that one or several states, party states, can press charges against Nicaragua at the International Court of Justice for violating the Convention and reducing the cases of people removed from their countries. And many people have been declared traitors to their homeland and arbitrarily deprived of their nationality. This is a state policy and a clear violation of the Convention, and no other country uses it arbitrarily or individually in the way that Nicaragua does. This is a very solid legal case, and the Court could decide in a few months and create provisional measures forcing Nicaragua to end those practices. And that's something that the Chilean government, along with other states, could perhaps encourage or consider. Second, the International Criminal Court. We all know that Nicaragua has not ratified the Treaty of Rome, and it's not a member, but its persecution against those who oppose the government, as we have heard, is crossing borders. In 2024, for example, it threw out 135 people, sent them to Guatemala, which is a party state of the International Criminal Court. And we have the president of Myanmar and Bangladesh, which shows that the Court can take action when a crime such as deportation takes place in a party state. So therefore, any party state could send that situation or bring it up to the prosecutors. Third, we have universal jurisdiction, which is a way for Augusto Pinochet and Javre to be accountable. And we have a case in Argentina where a judge issued an order to capture Daniel Ortega. But there are other countries that could also open cases, especially when there's a national that's their victim or there's a dictator to be found in their specific country. And fourth, the fourth way are selective sanctions. We've named 56 people. Many of them have been sanctioned, but half of those people have no sanctions at all and have not been sanctioned in the main jurisdictions. So each one of these avenues have effects at present. The International Court of Justice, as I said, could dictate provisional measures that would have an effect starting today, whenever they are put into place. An order of capture closes borders. An investigation makes every official understand that participating in abuse can have a personal cost. And for us, and we've seen that in many situations throughout the world, accountability isolates and protects. So I'm addressing the organizations that today are documenting while being in exile and risking everything. That you are the Roberto Garretons of Nicaragua. If there's no justice today, there will be justice tomorrow. But what we document today leads to that tomorrow arriving early. Thank you very much for that roadmap that you've given to civil society and the states. And thank you for the work that you've done. And we believe that the reports that you've drawn up in this all of the reports that you've drawn up since the creation of this group of experts is going to help us to seek justice in Nicaragua in the future. Thank you very much. The Special Rapporteur on the Independence of Judges and Lawyers has stated that the recent revocation of the licenses of 2,000 lawyers strikes at the very heart of the right of due process, that the legal profession has been the target of particular harassment in Nicaragua, and that the international community must take action to protect the independent spaces for organization, expression, and social participation that the Nicaraguan authorities have been attempting to shut down since 2018. Next, we will hear from Mrs. Margaret Satterwhite, who will brief us on recent findings and perspectives based on the work carried out by the Office of the Special Rapporteur. And I just want to thank so much Chile for this important event and the group of experts, as well as, of course, the Colectivo. It's really an honor to be here. And I will specifically, exactly address the situation of lawyers. So we've already heard such an important laying of the field, and specifically I just want to mention, before I look at lawyers, the dismantling of so many of the democratic institutions, included, of course, and perhaps most importantly for the protection of human rights, the dismantling of independent courts. And I think one of the things that we've been grappling with within my mandate is how to understand when courts become so instrumentalized and so captured that they're actually then themselves operators of a system of injustice and really need to be targeted specifically for accountability. I won't be talking about that today, but I think this case, of course, is a really important one here. So lawyers have also been specifically singled out. Lawyers who've represented political prisoners, defended human rights, or denounced state abuses, faced surveillance, harassment, threats, forced exile, restrictions on their practice, and then, of course, the cancellation of their professional registration, as well as other forms of reprisal. This is extremely serious. The lawyer right to a lawyer of one's choice is a core guarantee to a fair trial. So when it's taken away, you already have this incredible vulnerabilization of the ability to obtain a fair trial. Targeting lawyers, the authorities are really sending a chilling message to everyone. We can arrest you, and you will not have a lawyer of your own choice. You will not have an independent lawyer to protect your rights. On July 9, 2026, media outlets and judicial sources reported that approximately 2,000 lawyers had been removed from the official register of legal professionals kept by the Supreme Court of Justice. There was no prior notice. There was no administrative or disciplinary decision. There was no justification given. Judicial sources attribute the mask removal to a purge of the lawyers' database. And this kind of description of an incredibly problematic, abusive practice like this as a bureaucratic move, I think, is something very common to autocracies. A circular issued by the National Council for Judicial Administration and Careers on March 19 instructed magistrates, judges, and judicial bodies to verify that lawyers are on the judiciary's register before providing them any service and to refer those who are not on the directorate for the regulation, supervision, and control of lawyers and notaries. The practical effect of this is stark. Lawyers struck off the register can't represent their clients. They can't appear in proceedings and without any judicial ruling, disciplinary decision, or any due process at all. These removals strike at the heart of the right to fair trial. Administrative measures that in practice suspend or restrict the practice of law without procedural safeguards undermine fundamental guarantees and raise serious concerns for the rule of law and access to justice. The use of the disciplinary system and the regulatory powers of the Supreme Court of Justice to arbitrarily restrict the practice of law and notarial services, particularly against professionals considered critical of the government, is unfortunately nothing new in Nicaragua. On 9th and 11th of May 2023, as has already been referred to, the Supreme Court of Justice disbarred at least 26, but certainly more, lawyers and notaries under Special Law 1145. Most had also been stripped of their citizenship that February under Special Laws 1055 and 1145. Stripping individuals of their nationality is an especially egregious violation. We've already heard that. Nationality is the gateway to other rights. It's the right to have rights, as Hannah Arendt famously observed. Deprivation of nationality should only ever be a last resort. Where it's linked to alleged criminal offenses, the seriousness of the offenses, the standard of proof, and the evidence have to be rigorously assessed through an independent judicial process that fully protects the rights of those concerned. International standards are very clear here. States must ensure that lawyers can perform their professional functions without intimidation, hindrance, harassment, or undue interference, and they must never be sanctioned for acting in accordance with their professional duties, standards, and ethics. Any departure from these principles undermines the independence of the profession and the rights of everyone who relies on a lawyer to protect their fundamental freedoms. Disciplinary proceedings against lawyers have to respect due process, and they must be subject to independent review. At the regional level, the Inter-American Court of Human Rights has held that due process guarantees of Article 8 of the American Convention apply to all proceedings in which rights and obligations are determined. Any framework governing access to or exclusion from the legal profession must therefore respect the principles of legality, necessity, proportionality, transparency, and due process. Without these safeguards, decisions risk being arbitrary and incompatible with international obligations. Excluding so many lawyers from the register would also be incompatible with a prohibition on discrimination and the right to freedom of opinion and expression. States cannot discriminate against anyone on the basis of their opinions and especially may not exercise reprisal on the basis of opinion against professionals. I'm concerned that all of these exclusions breed a climate of fear, deter lawyers from taking on politically sensitive or even just regular criminal cases, and erode access to independent legal assistance. As my mandate warned in a report, protection of lawyers against undue interference in the free and independent exercise of the legal profession, the failure to grant professional licenses to lawyers associated with certain issues or opinions jeopardizes future generations of lawyers interested in the defense of human rights and fundamental freedoms. So it's really a generational impact that this kind of expulsion has. Using professional regulations in this way, in a way to single out, punish, and deter lawyers, really sets a worrying precedent and will continue to have reverberations over years. A number of lawyers who defended people persecuted for political reasons have also been arbitrarily detained and forcibly disappeared, possibly in retaliation for their work as lawyers. And I'm very concerned for those who are still missing for their welfare, their physical condition, and indeed their lives. I've shared my concerns with the Nicaraguan authorities, and today I add my voice to the call on the international community to step up and take more action, including this transnational repression that we're hearing about. I think it's very serious, and we need to ask states where people are being targeted to step up and protect them. Thank you very much. Thank you very much, Margaret. Muchísimas gracias. A continuación, quisiéramos agradecerle a usted y a los demás y. Thank you. We'd like to thank you and the other panelists for updating us. And, Mr. Ambassador, thank you once again. And thank you to GREN. Thank you, sir. Thank you to GREN as to Margaret for her presentation this afternoon. So we'd like to open a space for questions or comments. And if you could identify yourself, we'd be grateful so that we know who's taking the floor. Thank you. I'll hablar en español. Me llamo Rafael Viana. I am Rafael Viana with the International Service for Human Rights. I'm one of the organizers, but I had several questions. So please answer the questions that you think are most relevant, but they have to do with the various subjects brought up today and which have been stressed with certain recommendations by the group of experts. I have a question because we hear international repression. There are many efforts to ensure that the states who commit international repression be accountable. And we specifically want the protection for the people in the host country. So I'd like to ask the panelists from the civil society if you have any concrete recommendations for host countries who are protecting Nicaraguans. And the second question has to do with what is financially supporting repression in Nicaragua. It's clear that the co-presidents are not afraid of diplomatic isolation. So what's supporting this repression? And it's important that civil society reports and that we have economic and viable financial support. Claudia mentioned the fact that 12.5 percent of the territory is under concession to China, basically. And the Fundación del Río also published a report regarding this matter. We understand that almost a quarter of the Nicaraguan territory is under concession. So how can we answer how these benefits taken away from the indigenous populations are affecting the country? And if there are contaminations in Geneva and New York, we see that there's still development projects which are being carried out with the government without taking into account human rights. What's the role of the IMF and the Inter-American Bank? And how can we take into account these findings of terrible crimes with the United States or with the European Union? Thank you. Perhaps we can take two more questions and then we start. No? Okay. So then let's start. If you wish, I can address the transnational question, and then we can add more. The fact that there's a large amount of person and Nicaraguans exiled in other countries, such as Costa Rica, these places are very strong financial pressure on the state. However, this does not mean that the Costa Rican state has international obligations and committed in the framework of protection for the protection of human rights defenders, not just Nicaraguan defenders, but also in Costa Rica. So in that sense, I would like to say that in terms of transnational repression in Costa Rica, there is no system of human rights protection for the defenders of human rights that the program of witness protection in criminal cases exists. A group of us have asked for precautionary measures for victims who have been subjected to these violations in Costa Rica, and the Inter-American Court approved these measures. And so right now we're in discussions with Costa Rica to offer greater protection to these individuals. We know that there are very good examples or practices, per se. In Colombia, there's the unit of protection, national protection. And in terms of Colectivo 46.2, such as Organizaciones Memoria y Justicia, we are asking for the proposal that was made in terms of a protocol within the Inter-American Human Rights Protection Organization in order parting from the inputs that may be offered by civil society and the states in order to have a certain protocol. Having said this, what we are in pursuit of is not exclusive protection for Nicaraguans, but in countries where there isn't such protection system on human rights for those that work on human rights in the country. This regarding transnational repression, I don't know if maybe Claudia or Claudia would like to add something else. Maybe about financing and the financial support that the regime receives. It is clear to us that political pressure in and of itself has not really given great results in requiring the regime to open civic space or freeing political prisoners. And we also recognize that in terms of the management of the economy, the results are very different from Cuba or Venezuela. The results have not led to serious situations of hunger as has happened in other countries. We can also recognize that since Nicaragua is a country that is greatly linked to overseas in terms, there has been a great source of income for the country, around 30 percent of the gross domestic product of Venezuela comes from this industry and also of money wiring. And many financial international organizations that continue to issue loans to Nicaragua because in general sense they are fulfilling the macroeconomic obligations it has in order to continue to obtain loans. However, we have noticed that in every case, both in international financial situations and also in business and cooperation trade and cooperation agreements with the United States and the EU, that the conditions in the terms of human rights have not been met. This is an outstanding task. We must continue to put pressure on the fact that loans and any business or trade agreement be restricted or conditioned upon the enforcement of basic rights such as respect of democracy and human rights. And there is a pending, an outstanding agenda. It is very concerning because even though the Central American region is much closer to Nicaragua's situation, it continues to be one of the best financers or most common financers to the Nicaraguan regime, which creates great concern. Very briefly, just to reiterate what Claudia has just said, just a reminder that the Inter-American Human Rights Court on their temporary measures has owned the GREN report where it asks that the exercise of this collective right and there was a general obligation to offer protection for all those persons who were away from Nicaraguan territory and who are being affected. And also in the Inter-American system, they collected these recommendations from such an important group in order to protect, investigate, and sanction any human rights violations at the transnational level, especially the taking of life. And also remember something that we cannot lose sight of, which is corruption of the regime. Any loan, any agreement, any business or trade agreement is not only going to enrich the family in power in Nicaragua, but it will also nourish repression. I believe that this must be part and parcel of agreements, conventions, or loans, the obligation to enforce and respect human rights in Nicaragua. Just to deepen on this topic, in the institute, we produced a report called The Impact of International Financial Institutions in the Framework of the Nicaraguan Crisis. What we found is a lack of transparency to see how the resources for which they have been provided were really actually used for that, for those resources, including the study of loans by the World Bank in order to rebuild the coast after two hurricanes that impacted a portion of the northern coast of Nicaragua. They have received very significant loans, and there was a lack of transparency in order to find out how those resources were utilized. So we believe that a lot of the money that the Nicaraguan state applies for in order to build infrastructure, which is a great portion of what it should be utilized for, we really do not know if 100 percent of the loans were in fact used in infrastructure works, especially because of the lack of transparency. An interesting case, starting last year, Nicaraguan money remittances have doubled each year. And starting last year, the Nicaraguan Central Bank is not publishing the revenue it receives in wire money transmittances. And now we're talking 2024, 2022, 2023. It went from 1,000, 2,000, 3,000 or 4 billion, actually, what is sent by Nicaraguans in exile to Nicaragua. And then suddenly we don't have any data in the Nicaraguan Central Bank. So they're also hiding information that they're not making public. Any questions? Our report, I mean, we have a full report on transnational repression, but I did want to highlight that the rapporteurs have just come out with a very important statement on transnational repression, including measures that host states can take. And maybe you could. So great. So it's a bunch of mandate holders plus treaty body experts. We never get asked for these things. Okay. Well, most welcome. But it's called the Joint Statement by UN Human Rights Experts on Transnational Repression. If you Google it, you'll find it hopefully immediately. It's on the High Commissioner's website, and it was released about a month ago. It really goes through the kinds of transnational repression that have been reported here, but many others as well. And then there are very specific recommendations to states on how to make sure that, A, they're not participating in it, but also taking steps to stop it and to protect those who are victims of it. One thing that I just want to mention, because I know you all have mentioned it and it has come up in my work as well, is the abuse of red notices by Interpol. I think this is an issue that states really need to take up with Interpol because Interpol, of course, responds immediately to states and has a very, let's just call it, a process that many have seen as slow to respond to allegations of abuse of red notices. And so I think it's really important that states take the lead on this. And we've seen it in the experts' report, but also in a number of other reports and certainly by special rapporteurs. We see it a lot that red notices are emitted for people who are absolutely not responsible for the kinds of crimes that red notices are meant to be set out for. In terms of the financial institution beyond. And also a bit on TNR, you know, like a red notice is today, as of today, a standard practice on this side of the Atlantic, on the other side of the Atlantic and in Asia by rogue states. But what we have seen is the abuse of gray notices. So the SLTD Data Bank has been, to an extent, like misinformed that it would like have a direct effect of people trying to move from one country to the other. And this is much more subtile because you cannot trace this as easy as red notices. And what is even more subtile is having red-flagged and anti-money laundering compliance systems through private service providers, people of the opposition of Nicaragua. This is very sophisticated stuff. I particularly come from the field and I have seen this in very few cases. The question, of course, is why does this show up in the case of Managua? Having said this, you have a country where the director and the vice director of the financial intelligence unit are sanctioned. So the overall system, financial system of Nicaragua is not to be trusted. And the question is why the FATF directorate in October 2022 sacked them from the great list, whereas this year they're going to address Honduras to put it on the great list, where things are not fine, but not to the extent that you can see in Nicaragua. And then the additional question, which is very much related to this, is why does the International Monetary Fund in its Article Four assessments, when digging a bit deeper into questions of transparency, financial integrity, et cetera, doesn't red-flag the country as it should? And there is a bunch of other issues that we could address here. One thing which is very important in a world where international law and compliance with international law is in turmoil is that you have consented by Nicaragua on a bilateral, trilateral, multilateral treaty, which is a free trade agreement with the European Union in Article One and Two, clear commitments on the rule of law and human rights. This is the only framework of a free trade agreement where you have these clear commitments. There are some precedents in the case of Israel with the European Union and ACP states with the European Union. There is one precedent where this has been enforced now by a decision of the Commission last year. The question is, now that you have the big elephant in the room like Nicaragua, why does the Commission not act on this? You have been very active on this with race and equality, but I think there's a lot to do there because it is enforcement of international commitments through trade agreements where you do not unilaterally apply your own legislation as in the US Trade Act, the Section 301, like procedures are unilateral acts, in fact. This is not unilateral. These are commitments. So there's a bunch of things that we can do with this. Muchísimas gracias. Efectivamente, hay muchísimo más que podemos hacer. Thank you very much. There's a great deal more that we can have, and I'd like to thank you. We've given you a panorama and updated you of what's happening in Nicaragua at present. And we'd like to thank the GREN and the rapporteur for accompanying this afternoon, as well as the Chilean mission. And I'd like to give a final minute to Claudia Pineda so he can talk about Collectivo 46.2 for a closing statement. Ladies and gentlemen, thank you. As we conclude this dialogue, we would like to thank the permanent missions, representatives of international human rights mechanisms, civil society organizations, and individuals committed to the defense of human dignity. The crisis of human rights in Nicaragua cannot be only internal. It must be a concern of the international community. The crimes documented through independent mechanisms, such as a group of experts of the United Nations for Nicaragua, are concretely stating what the states must do and what the international institutions must do based on norms and standards. That's why we call firmly on the missions who are present here today. We ask you to keep Nicaragua among the priorities in the international human rights agenda. We ask you to continue backing and strengthening the mandates of international investigation and documentation. We ask you to continue to support and strengthen the mandates and that you support all efforts aimed at ensuring accountability for those responsible for serious human rights violations and possible crimes. We ask you to use the tools that international law makes available to the states to combat impunity, protect victims, and prevent the recurrence of these events. We ask you to continue offering effective protection to Nicaraguans who have been forced to flee their country and who continue to face risks even in exile. And above all, we ask you to listen to the victims and their families who for years have maintained their demand for justice in the face of silence, fear, and repression. Impunity is not inevitable. History shows that repressive systems can persist over time, but it also shows that the perseverance of the victims, accompanied by decisive action by the international community, can pave the way towards truth and justice. The Nicaraguan victims need solidarity, but also action, because without justice, there will be no guarantee of not repeating these events, and because without justice, there will be no guarantees of not repetition, and because without truth, justice, and reparations, it will not be possible to build a lasting peace and a genuine democracy for future generations of Nicaraguans. Thank you very much.